top of page

Top 10 Mistakes to Avoid When Owning a Herding Dog

Updated: Jun 11

Understanding Herding Dog Behavior

2 herding dog chasing after a herding ball on grasses
Herding Dog

10 Ownership Mistakes to Avoid with Herding Dogs: Expert TipsHerding dogs are a group of breeds, like a German shepherd originally bred for livestock herding and have evolved to become versatile workers and beloved pets, like Australian shepherds. Characterized by their intelligence, energy, and innate herding instincts, these dogs often display behaviors such as circling, nipping at heels, and a strong desire to herd moving objects, including people, especially children and other dogs or pets. This instinctual behavior is a reflection of breeding of those working dogs and requires understanding and proper management. Owners and trainers must channel these instincts positively through training, activities, and jobs that engage their body and mind, ensuring these dogs are well-adjusted and content.

Understanding the unique disposition and instincts of herding dogs is paramount to avoiding common ownership mistakes. Without recognizing how these traits manifest in day-to-day activities, Herding dog families might inadvertently suppress or mishandle their dog's natural behaviors, leading to frustration on both ends. For instance, not providing enough mental and physical stimulation can result in destructive behavior or excessive herding of inappropriate objects or even people. Misinterpreting their intelligence and need for engagement as mere disobedience can lead to ineffective training methods. Therefore, appreciating the underlying motives behind their actions is crucial for developing a harmonious relationship and ensuring their well-being. Here are some common mistakes you should avoid:

1. Failing to Provide Adequate Exercise

Most herding dogs are renowned for their high energy levels, a direct consequence of their breeding for demanding work environments. These breeds were developed to manage flocks and herds over vast, rugged terrains, often working from dawn until dusk. This historical context explains their remarkable stamina and need for vigorous daily exercise. Unlike many other dog breeds that may adapt to a more sedentary lifestyle, herding dogs retain their ancestors' indefatigable spirit. To remain healthy and happy, they require an outlet for their energy through extensive physical activity and mental challenges. Without this, they can become restless and exhibit problematic behaviors, signaling their unmet needs for stimulation and exertion.

To cater to the inherent needs of herding dogs, owners should integrate a blend of physical activities and mental stimulation into their daily routine. Engaging them in

a border collie sitting next to blue herding ball
Herding Dog

activities like agility training, frisbee, and flyball capitalizes on their physical agility and mental acuity, providing an appropriate outlet for their energy and intellect. Incorporating puzzle toys and interactive games can also be highly beneficial for mental engagement. For physical exercise, regular, lengthy walks in varied environments not only keep them physically fit but also offer new sensory experiences that nourish their curious minds. Establishing a routine that balances these elements is key to maintaining their physical health and emotional well-being, ensuring a fulfilled and harmonious life together.

2. Lack of Consistent Training

The importance of consistent, positive reinforcement training session cannot be overstated, especially for active and intelligent breeds like herding dogs. This approach, centered on rewarding desired behaviors rather than punishing undesired ones, fosters a strong bond between the dog and its owner, built on trust and mutual respect. It encourages the dog to repeat those positive behaviors in anticipation of rewards, which can range from treats to verbal praise or playtime. Consistency in training is crucial; irregular or mixed signals can confuse the dog, making the learning process longer and more frustrating for both parties involved. Additionally, positive reinforcement acknowledges the dog's natural instincts and intelligence, channeling their energy into constructive behaviors rather than suppressing their spirited nature. Through regular, positive training sessions, herding dogs can learn a variety of commands and tricks,

a german shepherd holding a red herding ball on grasses in front of fences in a backyard
Herding Dog

contributing to their mental stimulation and overall well-being, while also reinforcing their role as responsive and well-behaved companions.

Basic commands such as "sit," "stay," "come," "heel," and "down" form the foundation of any successful training regimen, acting as building blocks for more complex behaviors and enhancing communication between the dog and its owner. Once these fundamentals are mastered, owners can explore advanced training techniques like agility training, which includes navigating obstacles such as tunnels, weave poles, and jumps. This not only provides physical exercise but also mental stimulation and reinforces obedience under exciting conditions. Another advanced technique is scent work, where dogs use their natural sniffing abilities in structured activities or games, greatly enriching their mental engagement and offering a constructive outlet for their energy. These advanced techniques not only strengthen the bond between the dog and its owner but also elevate the dog's confidence and ability to handle different situations.

3. Ignoring Their Herding Instinct

Herding dogs, with their intrinsic herding instincts, can exhibit surprising behaviors in daily scenarios that reflect their ancestral duties. These instincts may manifest in seemingly harmless actions, such as gently nudging family members towards a collective area, or more challenging behaviors, such as circling and attempting to herd children, other pets, or even adults during walks or outdoor activities. This instinct is deeply rooted in their genetics and can be observed in their keen awareness of movement, which they may try to chase or direct. Understanding and acknowledging these instincts are crucial for pet owners, allowing them to channel these behaviors positively through structured training and activities that simulate herding tasks, thereby satisfying the dog's natural drives in a harmless and engaging manner.

Managing and redirecting the herding instinct in dogs requires creative strategies to satisfy their natural drives in a safe and controlled environment. One effective method is participating in organized herding activities or competitions specifically designed for these types of breeds, allowing them to engage in the behavior in an appropriate setting. For owners without access to herding activities, creating games that mimic herding tasks, such as guiding balls into designated areas, can also prove beneficial. Additionally, regular, structured exercise that challenges both the body and mind can help mitigate unwanted herding behavior by keeping the dog mentally and physically satisfied. Training that focuses on obedience and impulse control is also crucial, teaching the dog to look to their owner for direction rather than following their herding instinct indiscriminately.

4. Neglecting Socialization

Early socialization plays a pivotal role in preventing behavior issues in dogs, shaping them into well-adjusted adults. Introducing puppies to a wide range of people, animals, environments, and experiences during their critical socialization period, typically between three to fourteen weeks of age, is essential. This frequently exposure helps puppies learn to cope with new situations confidently and calmly, reducing the likelihood of fear-based reactions, such as aggression or anxiety, later in life. Socialization also allows puppies to develop appropriate social behaviors with both humans and other animals, preventing problematic behaviors stemming from fear or miscommunication. Carefully managed socialization experiences are key to ensuring a dog grows up to be a sociable, well-mannered, and adaptable pet, capable of handling the world’s complexities with ease.

For herding dogs, which naturally possess a strong instinct to manage and control their

an american bulldog standing behing a red herding ball on grasses in a park
Herding Dog

environment, socialization with other pets and humans requires thoughtful planning and execution. Initiating safe and controlled interactions in a secure, neutral space can prevent territorial behaviors and encourage positive experiences. It's beneficial to start with short, positive sessions, gradually increasing their duration and complexity as the dog becomes more comfortable. Employing positive reinforcement techniques, such as treats and praise, when the dog exhibits calm and friendly behavior towards others can reinforce desirable social traits. Additionally, closely monitoring the dog's body language for signs of stress or aggression and intervening when necessary helps to ensure all interactions remain positive. Facilitating controlled playdates with other well-socialized dogs and encouraging gentle, respectful interactions with humans of all ages can further enhance a herding dog's social adeptness.

5. Skimping on Mental Stimulation

Keeping a herding dog's mind active is crucial for their overall well-being, as these intelligent breeds thrive on mental engagement. Puzzle toys, which require dogs to solve problems to access treats, are an excellent way to stimulate their brains and stave off boredom. Training sessions that teach new tricks or reinforce existing commands not only provide mental exercise but also strengthen the bond between dog and owner.

an australian shepherd chasing after a herding ball on grasses
Herding Dog

Interactive games like hide-and-seek, where the dog must find their owner or specific toys hidden around the house or yard, offer both mental and physical exercise. Treibball, a sport designed specifically for herding breeds, mimics the traditional work of sheep herding and provides an excellent outlet for their natural instincts and energies. By incorporating these activities into their daily routine, owners can help ensure their herding dogs remain mentally sharp, engaged, and happy.

The impact of mental stimulation on a herding dog's overall behavior cannot be overstated. Engaging their minds through activities like puzzle solving, interactive play, and sport mimicking traditional herding tasks significantly affects their temperament and behavior. Dogs that regularly receive mental exercise tend to display fewer behavioral problems, such as excessive barking, digging, and other forms of destructive behavior often rooted in boredom and frustration. Furthermore, mental stimulation enhances their learning capabilities, making them more receptive to obedience training and improving their problem-solving skills. Thus, a mentally stimulated herding dog is generally more balanced, focused, and content, contributing to a harmonious relationship with their owner and a more peaceful household environment.

6. Overlooking Grooming and Health Care

Herding dog breeds, with their diverse coat types and active lifestyles, have specific grooming needs that require attention for their overall well-being. These dogs often possess thick, double coats that provide insulation and protection but also tend to collect dirt and debris. Regular brushing, at least once a week, is essential to remove loose fur, prevent matting, and distribute skin oils evenly across the coat, promoting a healthy shine. During shedding seasons, more frequent grooming may be necessary to manage the increased hair loss. Additionally, their active nature means they may require more frequent nail trims to prevent overgrowth and splitting, which can be painful and impair mobility. Ear cleaning is also crucial, especially for those breeds with floppy ears, as their active lifestyle can lead to a buildup of dirt and increase the risk of ear infections. Addressing the specific grooming needs of herding dogs not only contributes to their physical health but also enhances their comfort and quality of life.

Regular health check-ups play a crucial role in maintaining the health and longevity of herding dogs. Annual visits to the veterinarian for comprehensive examinations ensure early detection and management of potential health issues. Herding breeds are predisposed to certain genetic conditions, including hip dysplasia, collie eye anomaly, and degenerative myelopathy, among others. Prompt and periodic screenings for these conditions can significantly mitigate their impact. Vaccinations, parasite control, and dental care are also integral components of a herding dog's health regimen, safeguarding them from common diseases and complications. Being proactive about health care through regular check-ups and being vigilant for signs of illness can lead to a healthier, happier life for these active and loyal companions.

7. Misunderstanding Their Dietary Needs

The nutritional requirements of herding dogs are distinct and should be meticulously

2 herding dog chasing after a herding ball on grasses
Herding Dog

considered to avoid common dietary mistakes. These energetic and active breeds require a balanced diet rich in proteins to support muscle maintenance and carbohydrates for sustained energy. However, a frequent oversight is not adjusting their caloric intake according to their activity level, leading to underfeeding in highly active dogs or overfeeding in less active ones, both of which can have health implications. Equally important is the quality of the food; opting for high-quality, breed-specific dog food can prevent nutritional imbalances. Supplements might be beneficial, but only when used under veterinary guidance, as excessive supplementation can be detrimental. Avoiding human food that is harmful to dogs, such as chocolate, onions, and grapes, is crucial, as is ensuring they have constant access to fresh water, especially after strenuous activities.

Choosing the right food and supplements for herding dogs necessitates careful consideration of their unique energy and nutritional requirements. It's advisable to consult with a veterinarian to select a high-quality dog food that meets the specific needs of the breed, ensuring it's formulated to support their active lifestyle. Look for foods that list real meat, vegetables, and whole grains as primary ingredients to provide a balanced mix of proteins, fats, and carbohydrates. When it comes to supplements, avoid unnecessary additions unless recommended by a vet, as some can do more harm than good if not used appropriately. Key supplements that might be beneficial include those for joint support, especially for older dogs or those with a predisposition to joint issues, and omega fatty acids for healthy skin and coat. Always introduce any new food or supplement gradually into their diet to monitor for any adverse reactions.

8. Underestimating the Need for Strong Leadership

The importance of establishing and maintaining strong leadership in the context of herding dogs cannot be overstated. These intelligent and energetic breeds thrive under the guidance of a confident leader who sets clear boundaries and expectations. Strong leadership not only prevents the development of unwanted behaviors but also fosters a healthy, respectful relationship between the dog and its owner. With their innate drive to work and please, herding dogs look to their human counterparts for direction and purpose. By consistently demonstrating leadership, owners can effectively channel their dog's energy into positive activities, enhancing obedience, and ensuring their well-being. Thus, the role of the owner as a leader is fundamental in unlocking the full potential of their herding dog, making training more effective and the bond between them stronger.

Lack of leadership can significantly contribute to behavioral problems in herding dogs, whose innate need for directed activity and guidance may go unmet. Without a clear leader to follow, these intelligent and active dogs may resort to self-directed activities, often manifesting as destructive behaviors or excessive barking. This absence of direction can also lead to anxiety and confusion, undermining the dog's confidence and potentially fostering aggressive tendencies in an attempt to establish order in their perceived hierarchy. Therefore, establishing oneself as a calm, consistent, and strong leader is paramount in preventing such behavioral issues, ensuring a harmonious and balanced relationship with the dog.

9. Failing to Establish Boundaries and Rules

a border collie sitting next to blue herding ball
Herding Dog

Establishing clear boundaries and rules is essential for a harmonious living situation with herding dogs. These intelligent and energetic breeds thrive on structure and predictability, which help them understand their environment and what is expected of them. Without clear boundaries, dogs can become confused and stressed, potentially leading to unwanted behaviors such as excessive barking, chewing, or even aggression. Clear rules not only provide a framework for acceptable behavior but also enhance the dog's security and confidence by offering a consistent and predictable environment to watch. Furthermore, when dogs know the limits of their behavior, it strengthens the bond between them and their owners, fostering a relationship built on mutual respect and understanding. Setting and enforcing boundaries from the outset can prevent many behavioral problems and contribute to a peaceful and cooperative household.

To effectively set and enforce rules for herding dogs, begin with simple commands like "sit," "stay," and "come," ensuring consistency in their use. Consistency is key; use the same words and gestures for each command, helping your dog understand and remember them. Positive reinforcement, such as treats or praise, should be employed promptly when the dog obeys, reinforcing the desired behavior. Establishing a routine for feeding, walking, and resting can also help enforce discipline, as these breeds thrive on predictability. When correcting unwanted behavior, focus on redirection rather than punishment; introduce a preferred behavior or command to replace the undesired action. Finally, remember that patience and repetition are critical. Training is an ongoing process that strengthens the bond between you and your dog, fostering a relationship of mutual respect and understanding.

10. Not Preparing for Their Vocalness

Understanding the reasons behind a herding dog's vocal behaviors is crucial in addressing and managing it appropriately. Herding breeds, known for their vocalness, often use barking as a tool for communication and as a method derived from their herding instincts. This vocal behavior can be attributed to several factors, including alerting their owners to potential threats, expressing excitement or anxiety, or simply as a way of seeking attention. Recognizing the context of their barking can help owners discern between barks that signal genuine concern versus those that are habitual or attention-seeking. By acknowledging these underlying reasons, owners can employ more effective strategies tailored to mitigate excessive barking without stifling their natural tendencies to communicate.

Australian shepherd and its red herding ball in the bushes in a backyard
Herding Dog

Managing and reducing excessive barking or herding noises in herding breeds requires a strategic approach that respects their natural instincts while promoting desirable behavior. One effective strategy is consistently engaging them in physical and mental exercise to dissipate excess energy and reduce boredom, a common trigger for unnecessary barking. Implementing training sessions that focus on quiet commands can also be beneficial. These sessions teach the dog to cease barking on command, reinforcing silence with rewards. Additionally, socialization plays a pivotal role; exposing the dog to various sounds, environments, and situations can decrease their sensitivity over time, making them less likely to bark at every stimulus. It's important to remain calm and composed when addressing vocal behaviour, as dogs can pick up on their owner's frustration, potentially exacerbating the issue. By combining exercise, training, socialization, and an understanding response to their needs, owners can effectively manage and mitigate unwarranted vocalizations.


In summary, successful ownership of herding breeds hinges on a few key strategies that take into account their unique behavioral traits and natural instincts. To manage and reduce excessive barking and fulfill their herding inclinations, it is essential to provide ample physical and mental stimulation through regular exercise and engaging activities. Implementing quiet command training, supplemented with positive reinforcement, helps establish effective communication and control. Early and consistent socialization introduces the dog to various stimuli, reducing their reactionary barking. Finally, understanding and patience from the owner, recognizing the difference between attention-seeking and instinctual behavior, foster a healthy and happy relationship. Remembering these strategies can significantly enhance the bond between owner and dog, ensuring a fulfilling life together.

Taking the time to learn and grow alongside your herding dog can deepen the bond of companionship to new levels. This shared journey of discovery not only enhances your dog’s life but enriches yours with unparalleled fulfillment. Engaging in activities that challenge both you and your dog, such as advanced training classes, herding trials, or agility courses, can be a rewarding way to harness their natural abilities while fostering mutual respect and understanding. Remember, every moment of training and every challenge overcome is an opportunity to build trust and cooperation. By committing to this continuous path of learning and growth, you ensure a dynamic and enriching partnership with your herding dog that lasts a lifetime.

117 views0 comments


bottom of page